• Knight Frank advocates Government to adopt public private partnerships to unlock private land reserve

    7 September 2018

    (5 September 2018, Hong Kong) The government’s public consultations to gather views on the Private Recreational Lease policy and the public private partnerships (PPP) will soon come to an end. Alnwick Chan, Executive Director and Head of Valuation & Professional Services at Knight Frank has shared the following views regarding to these two topics.


    Review of the Policy of Private Recreational Leases

    The government’s six-month public consultation to gather views on the recommendations of reviewing the Private Recreational Lease policy will soon come to an end. The review report proposed changes to the current Private Recreational Lease arrangements and lease conditions, which includes granting a concessionary premium, equivalent to one-third of the full market land premium, to private recreational clubs who are eligible to the renewal conditions. Alnwick Chan said that since most, if not all, private sports clubs are non-profit oriented or budgeted to break even, or even making operating loss, their sites would only command nominal premium from a land valuation perspective. Therefore, Knight Frank recommend a nominal land premium to be charged for private recreational clubs. The land usage, lease terms and the restrictions in land leases governing these private sports clubs cannot be objectively compared or benchmarked against transactions of commercial properties in the open market, and there is also no market comparable for assessing the full market value of these sites.

    In case of the government’s objection on granting a nominal premium, Knight Frank recommends an annual levy based on a particular percentage of the rateable value. Similar to the government rent calculation, the rateable value could be revised on annual basis of in line with the market sentiment. If the private clubs are required to pay the premium or levy annually, they should have sufficient time to raise funding. Regardless of the level of the land premium, the government should recognise the private recreational clubs’ operating and financial constraints, the restrictions imposed under the lease conditions and their contribution to the society.

    In order to encourage private clubs to invest into the future, promote sports and provide quality facilities to both members and non-members, the government should offer a longer lease term. Knight Frank recommends those private recreational leases expiring in or leases being extended at nominal premium to 2027 should be granted a lease renewal for 21 years + 15 years, subject to the annual levy or premium and Home Affairs Bureau’s policies.

    In addition, Knight Frank pointed out that the proposed instalment option to existing private recreational leases, similar to that under the industrial revitalisation scheme, might not be attractive to private clubs. Such instalment option has yet been taken up by industrial building owners due to high interest rates. Knight Frank also opposes the proposal to restrict and regulate the issuing and trading of debentures as this is against the principle of free market and interfere with private clubs’ operation.


    Public Private Partnerships (PPP)

    The Task Force on Land Supply is actively looking into various ways to boost land supply. Currently it has proposed 18 short-, medium- to long-term options to increase land supply, of which three of them involve private land, including developing brownfield sites, tapping into private agricultural reserves in the New Territories of private developers and developing new towns in the New Territories.

    Since it is currently a lengthy process for the Hong Kong government to resume private land under the “Lands Resumption Ordinance” and also because of the inflexibility in the existing mechanism in terms of issues such as compensation and rehousing, it is a challenge for development projects to be completed on time, especially for subsidised flats. In additional, the government can hardly allocate resources to resume multiple sites to launch development at the same time. Therefore, it should look into other methods to shorten the process and one of the options is public private partnerships.

    By adopting PPP model, private developers can enhance the cost effectiveness of the development based on their individual project experience, lowering the inputs required and risks borne by the Government. Considering the existing compensation mechanism of Government land resumption is rather inflexible, the application of PPP can avoid Government resuming private land and confronting associated social issues. Alnwick Chan expected that the development timeline of subsidised flats could be fast-tracked by 3-5 years through PPP compared with using “Land Resumption Ordinance”. As Hong Kong is currently facing the issue of land shortage to develop subsidised flats, the Government should create private incentives to draw private participation from those developers who own land reserve. Alnwick Chan also suggested the ratio of subsidised flats to total housing provision in the PPP proposals could be 20-40% in general and capped at 50% to create sufficient private incentives in participating the development of subsidised flats.

    Alnwick advocated the Government to establish an independent committee for approving PPP projects. By maintaining high transparency, it could eliminate the public concern on collusion. The committee should be chaired by the Chief Executive, with its role confined to the approval of PPP proposals and to confirm the ratio of subsidised flats in different projects. Once the ratio has been confirmed, the development proposal should be passed on to Town Planning Board and Lands Department to manage the planning process and to resolve technical issues, avoiding duplication of responsibilities among the organisations. Alnwick also suggested to adopt a scoring system based on certain criteria, which not only consider the ratio of subsidised flats in PPP proposals but also factor in elements which serve public interests. In addition, land with high ecological value should be conserved. By adopting criteria which are fair, justice and open, it should eliminate public’s suspicion on the Government’s preference in engaging major developers.

    In conclusion, in regard to the Task Force’s proposal to increase land supply, Knight Frank supports the options of developing brownfield sites and tapping into private agricultural reserves in the New Territories to increase short- and medium-term land supply. It is believed that reclamation outside the Victoria Harbour, the development of East Lantau Metropolis and new development areas in the New Territories are feasible options to help tackle the ongoing issue of land shortage in Hong Kong in the medium-to-long term. In addition to that, topside development of existing transport infrastructure and public utilities sites are feasible conceptual options.


    For further information, please visit KnightFrank.com.hk.




    More Real Estate
    Asia Pacific investment volumes hit record US$81 billion in first half of 2018
    (27 August 2018, Hong Kong) Investment volumes in Asia Pacific hit a record-breaking US$81 billion in the first half of 2018, up by 30 per cent year-on-year, according to the latest data from real estate consultancy JLL. Hong Kong led the way as the region’s most active city and among the top three most liquid markets worldwide with transaction volumes hitting US$14.6 billion. Of [...]
    Bangkok to be the site of the first Four Seasons Private Residence waterfront development in Asia
    (August 2018, Bangkok) Thailand-based international real estate developer Country Group Development PCL (CGD) and Four Seasons Hotels and Resorts today revealed the masterplans for Bangkok’s Chao Phraya Estate, featuring Four Seasons Private Residences Bangkok at Chao Phraya River; and two ultra-luxury hotels including Four Seasons Hotel Bangkok at Chao Phraya River. The baht 32 billion [...]
    More luxury flats headed for the leasing market as developers seek to minimise the impact of new vacancy tax
    (31 July 2018, Hong Kong) – About 1,500 luxury units (Class E flat, saleable area of 1,722 sq ft or above) will come on stream over the next 30 months. To minimise the impact of the new vacancy tax, developers are likely to switch more unsold luxury flats from the sales to leasing market, according to JLL’s the latest Residential Sales Market Monitor released today. At the end of [...]
    Citi HK Releases Results of 2nd Quarter 2018 Residential Property Ownership Survey Expectations for housing prices
    (26 July 2018, Hong Kong) Citi Hong Kong announced today the results of the latest Hong Kong Residential Property Ownership Survey. The bank commissioned The University of Hong Kong Social Sciences Research Centre to conduct a telephone survey, interviewing over 500 Hong Kong respondents selected by random digital dialing in June of 2018. Record Number of Respondents Expected Housing Prices [...]
    Asia Pacific shows fastest progress in real estate transparency
    (2 July 2018, Hong Kong)  Asia Pacific’s mature economies such as Singapore, Hong Kong and Japan, have a significant opportunity to advance real estate transparency through proptech adoption. These leading investment destinations are on the cusp of the ‘Highly Transparent’ tier, according to JLL’s Global Real Estate Transparency Index (GRETI) 2018, and are poised to join the top [...]
    Habitat Property forecasts strong performance for Hong Kong’s luxury residential market
    (June 2018, Hong Kong)  – As the first half of 2018 comes to a close, real estate entrepreneur Victoria Allan has an optimistic outlook for Hong Kong’s burgeoning luxury residential property market. The founder of leading boutique real estate agency Habitat Property, Victoria has gained a reputation as a housing guru with a passion for discovering truly unique Hong Kong [...]
    Colliers International releases Colliers Flash: Hong Kong retail sector Q1
    (25 June 2018, Hong Kong) — Colliers International (NASDAQ: CIGI; TSX: CIGI), a global leader in commercial real estate services, has released the latest flash report for Hong Kong’s retail sector after a strong rebound. The report highlights the latest news and trends in the retail property market, focusing on the sector’s impressive start into 2018 with retail sales from January [...]
    Vacancy tax, a double-edged sword to housing market
    (25 June 2018, HONG KONG) Housing prices are unlikely to reverse course in the short-term, assuming the government introduces a vacancy tax similar to the level of government rates. But developers are expected to turn less aggressive in land bidding, according to JLL’s monthly Residential Sales Report released today. There is growing anticipation for the government to announce a vacancy tax [...]
    Colliers International releases Colliers Flash: Hong Kong retail sector Q1
    (25 June 2018, Hong Kong)  Colliers International (NASDAQ: CIGI; TSX: CIGI), a global leader in commercial real estate services, has released the latest flash report for Hong Kong’s retail sector after a strong rebound. The report highlights the latest news and trends in the retail property market, focusing on the sector’s impressive start into 2018 with retail sales from [...]