• As the likelihood of land reclamation strengthens, so does the need to consider alternatives to conventional reclamation

    8 March 2019

    Story by Rupert Leung, Managing Director, Engineering, Arcadis


    Land supply remains at the core of Hong Kong’s housing challenge and at the top of the news agenda. The government-appointed Task Force on Land Supply says Hong Kong needs to find 1,200 hectares of land for housing, and last year, Chief Executive Carrie Lam unveiled the government’s ‘Lantau Tomorrow Vision’ which looks to create 1,700 hectares through reclamation.

    Hong Kong is no stranger to land reclamation with the first project undertaken by the British colonial authorities in 1851. Now around 6% of Hong Kong’s total area is reclaimed land, accommodating about 27% of the city’s population, and as much as 70% of Hong Kong’s commercial activities.

    While the conversation continues around whether or not to reclaim more land, and if so where to do it, it is important that the Hong Kong community has a full understanding of the process, including the potential risks and benefits. It is of critical importance that the people of Hong Kong have an informed voice during the consultation process and are engaged with at an early stage, with regular dialogue to address topics such as cost and environmental impacts, and in the process creating ownership among the people of Hong Kong.   

    The Polder method offers an alternative to conventional reclamation. It originates from the Netherlands, where half the country is at or below sea level and over centuries, the Dutch have constructed about 3,000 polders. The method is also being increasingly adopted throughout the world, with Asian counterparts Singapore using this method. Unlike the traditional method of reclamation, where filling has to be carried out to higher than sea level, the Polder method involves creating a tract of land by enclosing an area within the sea by dykes and pumping the water out. The polder is then kept dry with a network of drains, reservoirs and pumping stations.

    When compared with traditional land reclamation, which involves filling and taking into account storm surges and sea level rise, the Polder method substantially reduces the amount of fill material needed, lowering the upfront construction cost – especially in Hong Kong where fill resource is scarce and often has to be imported.  In fact, lowering the reclamation level by several meters, even still maintained to be above sea level, would create substantial saving in construction time and cost.

    Polder development has higher long-term maintenance cost when taking into account the costs associated with operating and maintaining the flood protection system and the pumping stations. Nevertheless, such costs can be reduced by the adoption of renewable energy, such as the use of wind turbines, which has historically harnessed by windmills in the Netherlands.

    Polder is not an entirely new concept to Hong Kong. In fact, similar ideas and designs have been adopted by the government to tackle flooding in low-lying areas in the New Territories. Embankments, drainage channels, flood storage ponds and pumping stations were built to successfully protect low-lying villages from flooding.

    Whether using the Polder method or not, reclamation needs to work with the environment and should be considered in their planning and design to minimize effects to natural habitats. This calls for Building with Nature, a philosophy of harnessing the forces of nature to benefit environment, economy and society. The incorporation of beaches, mangroves, and wetlands strengthens the coast line in natural ways, allows the ecology to be sustained, plants and wildlife to be cultivated, as well as improving quality of life of habitants.    

    As a Dutch consultancy, Arcadis has been involved with Polder developments for over a century, providing design and construction inputs to almost all Polder projects in the Netherlands, as well as in other countries. Arcadis is also a leading party in the development and implementation of the Building with Nature concept.





    More Opinion & Interviews
    Shaping the Future of Architectural Design in China
    China has seen phenomenal developments of its building industry over the past few decades, mirroring the frenetic growth of the domestic economy. Along with the rising skyline, both homegrown and international architectural design firms have found a wealth of opportunities to capitalize on their expertise, though the challenges they face are no less challenging. Lead 8, an international [...]
    Aviation infrastructure-enhancing customer experience
    Benoy CEO, Tom Cartledge, discusses the future of aviation and his international practice’s growing involvement with a global sector experiencing surging increases in passenger numbers and soaring demand for innovative new airport infrastructure. 1. What does Changi Terminal 4 represent for Benoy in terms of your reputation as a global practice? The great thing about Changi is their [...]
    RICS Dispute Resolution Service
    With its primary function to set standards across the property and construction sectors and to regulate the conduct of over 200,000 members around the world, RICS is celebrating its 150th anniversary this year. Sitting within RICS is the Dispute Resolution Service (DRS) which for the past 42 years -has been appointing arbitrators, adjudicators, and experts across the built environment. John [...]
    The Problem with BIM
    The AEC industry, architecture, engineering and construction, is going through very exciting times like no other before. We are witnessing the integration of virtual design and construction with human computer interaction, augmented reality, BIM, Point Cloud, 3D scanning and more. These technologies are changing the way projects are delivered creating a new level of collaboration, which is [...]
    Activity-based workspaces in Asia Pacific
    (3 January 2018, Asia Pacific) As companies in the Asia Pacific region remain under pressure to make savings and implement transformational change, many look toward new workplace strategies. Are agile workspaces always the answer? Can they suit the needs of all organisations and all employees? Workplace strategy thinking has traditionally been led by companies originating in Europe and [...]
    CEO Talk
    Vivien Chan, SBS, BBS, JP, founded V Group in 1994. It has been developing “V Serviced Apartments” since 2006 and the first “V Hotel” was launched in 2013. Earlier in 2017 V Group opened its first purpose-built residential project, Castle One by V, under the “V Residences” brand.  After a series of media events held over the summer, PRC Magazine met with Ms Chan to discuss [...]
    PRC Magazine spoke to Torben Hansen
    Torben Hansen of Schotten & Hansen about his humble beginnings and a journey that has led his company to the top league of international craftsmanship. 01. When did your love of timber begin and how did this lead to the establishment of a globally renowned supplier of high-quality timber flooring and interior solutions? As a child, I earned money for the first time by burning furniture. I [...]
    Walking the talk towards the modern workplace
    With advances in technology yielding increased connectivity, more thought than ever is being given to where and how we work. In an initiative led by recruitment firm Bespoke Careers, a collection of real estate executives, interior designers and workplace strategists working across the Asia Pacific region came together for a roundtable discussion at MMosers’s [...]
    Hotels. Transformation.
    The hotel design market is being tailored to an ever more granular level to meet the demands of a diversifying and growing market that is increasingly aware. Common to the experiences of both low budget and high roller travellers however, will always be the idea behind the need for hotels: Place. We are all from somewhere and we travel for many reasons. Hotels and accommodations are key to [...]